# Comparison quality review — 17 November 2026

Scope: all retained award records and display mappings across44 programme IDs; both award and programme-earning lenses. Existing research and record IDs were reused. Independent challenges covered Europe/MENA awards, APAC/Americas awards and earning logic. This review does not certify every market, transaction or unpublished entitlement.

## Outcome

Source-qualified management discussion edition. Verified facts remain scoped; unknown is not a non-offer. No zero-error or exhaustive worldwide catalogue claim is made.

- 285 source-linked award records;45 distinct display benefit rows across the full benchmark.
- 43 structured programme summaries and78 retained tier records reconciled; IndiGo’s missing structured earning summary stays visible as UNKNOWN.
- 17 award records remain unconfirmed and are excluded from offered coverage.
- PPB remains the reference, excluded from the competitor denominator; each other programme counts once per benefit.

## Corrections

| Area | Correction |
|---|---|
| Iberia / On Business | Added scoped direct-discount choice and voucher-funded benefits. Spain voucher model separated from retained BA/UK points model; no discount-plus-earning stacking. |
| Singapore | Added milestone lounge/Scoot voucher, IHG partner discounts/status, Pelago vouchers and reservation/standby priority. Generic IHG referral display superseded by explicit hotel mappings; ID retained. |
| Personal earning | Added missing bluebiz redemption-ticket personal earning and Aeromexico simultaneous personal earning; no implied double company credit on redemption. |
| Finnair | Added scoped disruption support, without claiming priority over other customers. |
| airBaltic / THAI | Added documented fare/contract-linked inclusions; corporate-context scope retained. |
| IndiGo | Meal discount removed from verified coverage because current indexed terms specify market-rate snacks. Fast Forward remains unconfirmed pending governing-source inspection; no general fare discount inferred. |
| Display / filters | Consolidated name changes, booking changes, meal types and hotel earning. Delta eCredit no longer overlaps the Other access filter. PPB tooltip accurately explains denominator exclusion. |

## Remaining evidence limits

- Iberia market/version rollout and exact spend-boundary wording are not resolved into a universal model.
- IndiGo current direct source body is blocked; indexed-only seat/FastForward/fee claims are not promoted to broad confirmed access.
- Existing TAP and RAM source conflicts, Garuda current-entitlement gaps and Cathay campaign-only upgrade limits remain visible.
- Personal reward catalogues are not automatically imported just because company value can transfer to a traveller account.
- A source link establishes traceability, not equal evidence strength or universal eligibility.

## Acceptance

Syntax, source-trace, unique-row and targeted correction checks pass. Completeness covers44 programmes,285 awards,430 fields,78 tiers,141 capabilities and1037 retained evidence records. Automated coverage/filter scenarios and desktop acceptance are recorded in RELEASE_REVIEW.md. Programme facts were not changed to force a stronger PPB positioning; scoring and the six strategic bets are unchanged.
