# PPB management comparison — completion and release assessment

17 November 2026

## Decision
The requested two-lens management comparison is completed within its stated evidence limits and available for the user's final review. This is not approval by the user or a claim of complete knowledge of every airline benefit. The earlier 80% estimate was subjective and is superseded by the explicit acceptance criteria below.

| Acceptance criterion | Result | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Awards and programme/earning lenses | PASS | Both existing views retained |
| Whole benchmark and comparable peer selection | PASS |44 retained programme records, PPB pinned; regional and scope filters |
| Discounts separated; duplicate award types bundled | PASS | Existing normalized rows and access labels retained |
| Counts, percentages and multi-select filters | PASS |1,101 scenarios; unique programme numerator; PPB excluded; separate access included and labelled |
| Traceable retained evidence | PASS |250 award records linked; programme source details on demand |
| Identified targeted research queue adjudicated | PASS |159 findings:44 accepted,113 qualified,2 separate products held |
| Remaining uncertainty handled fairly | PASS for disclosure |238 programme fields and15 active award records remain unconfirmed; they are not factual closures |
| Separate product boundary resolved for this release | EXCLUDED |JAL JCFM and EVA x UATP stay outside existing mapped programmes; no ID changes |
| Every programme equally researched and all claims fully verified | NOT MET |No such sign-off; partial summaries and source conflicts remain |
| Universal customer-value ranking | OUT OF SCOPE |Different currencies, markets and access gates are not normalized here |
| Management approval | NOT GIVEN |User review remains outstanding |

## Important remaining factual limits
Royal Air Maroc beneficiary/award document conflicts, Cathay campaign entitlement/paid SAF distinction, AEGEAN earning-period interaction, THAI contractual thresholds, Etihad expiry FAQ/terms conflict and some current commercial conditions remain qualified. Legacy Air Canada rows are not imported into Embarq. Current Embarq fare and personal-point offers are dated through10 December2026. Missing values are not zero and unknown awards are not non-offers. Indexed or blocked sources retain their limitations.

The accompanying CSV lists every remaining unconfirmed structured programme field and active award record, its known information, qualification, retained source links and release handling. Treat it as an unresolved-question register, not a claim that no public information exists.

## What is complete
Research reconciliation, adjudication of the identified findings, integration, source disclosure, functional checks and explicit release scope are completed. Further evidence can improve the knowledge base, but no pending research-review queue is being presented as a finished factual answer.
